The Reason Why Students Should Familiarize Themselves with the Real World of Ethical Dilemmas at the Early Stages of Learning Accounting
This is the time when the accounting profession is at a crossroads. Accountants are the keepers of financial integrity, and as Ghana remains on its mission of economic transformation and digitalization, one can only imagine how important the role of accountants in the sphere is. However, with the recent corporate scandals all over the world and in light of the new challenges in financial reporting, we have found that there exists a line of communication between theory and the ethical conduct of accounting professionals. It is out of this gap that there should be an urgent need to rethink the way we should prepare the future generation of accountants, especially the ethics side of financial reporting.
The Need for Early Ethical Instruction
The historical mode of accounting education has always been focused on competency, the ability to learn the debits and credits, learn the financial statements, and learn the intricate regulatory frameworks. The skills, although they remain the fundamental ones, are not enough in the current dynamic business environment. The downfall of some big companies (Enron and the recent events) attributed to accounting anomalies all speaks of how technically savvy individuals whose code of conduct has no footing on ethics can get themselves into such a sorry state.
Research conducted by the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) revealed that 73% of participants in the accounting profession experience ethics in the first five years of practice. Surveys, however, indicate that a substantial portion of humans believe that they are not prepared to handle such issues in an effective way, typically because of a perceived incomplete exposure to on-the-job ethical education in their school years. This lack of connection between education and practice forms a perilous gap in which newly qualified accountants are forced to learn ethics by trial and error, as opposed to it being an element of luxury that the profession and the society cannot afford.
Learning the Ethical Scenario of Financial Reporting
Financial reporting ethics is more than just not having fraud or embezzlement. It is about finding a way through tricky circumstances where business judgment, stakeholders, and key regulation overlap. Think of the increasing frequency of earnings management, in which corporations employ accounting discretion in order to satisfy the analysts or to make debt covenants. Although they are technically legal, such activities harbor serious doubts about faithful reporting of financial performance.
These difficulties are enhanced in the case of Ghana by the fact that international financial reporting standards coincide with local activities in the business field as well as cultural issues. With the introduction of IFRS, the new requirements of transparency are also added, but it also introduced the new judgment areas where the ethical issues emerge to the fore. As an example, valuation of biological assets in the agricultural sector in Ghana or accounting treatment of government grants in the mining industry cannot just be done based on technical knowledge but also on an ethical framework to make it fair.
The Argument of Practical Ethical Fusion
It is important that real-world ethical dilemmas be integrated into accounting education and serve several purposes. To begin with, it closes the theory-practice divide since the students learn the realities of business situations, which are not as simple as they seem. Unlike the textbook examples that have definite answers, the real-world cases usually have multiple interests of stakeholders, vague regulatory directions, and tight time scales, which are analogous to professional practice.
Second, initial exposure to the ethical dilemmas enables formation of the critical thinking, which is indispensable in professional performance. The students get to learn how to recognize the ethical problems, understand the effects of stakeholders, and assess other avenues of action. This very process of ethical reasoning gets adopted, which forms the basis of a good decision-making process when they embark on their working lives.
Third, ethical education in a case-based method makes students realize the social and economic consequences of their actions in their fields of work. As the students learn to examine the impact that accounting decisions have on the lives of investors, creditors, employees, and communities, they learn to become more appreciative of being the custodian of the financial information. It is this view that is of special interest in Ghana, where the accounting professionals can be found playing a strategic role in small and medium enterprises, which are the mainstay of the economy.
Relevant Strategies to Ethical Integration
The best approaches to financial reporting ethics integration need to be multidimensional and involve both theory and practice. The most effective means of this integration is, nevertheless, case study methodology. Nevertheless, it is imperative that these cases are well chosen so as to demonstrate the various moral issues that are experienced by accounting practitioners.
As an example, the students may examine the ethics of a manufacturing company in making a decision on capitalizing versus excluding research and development costs on the effects on different stakeholders and on whether the business can survive in the long term. And likewise, they may consider the problems encountered by auditors in having to yield to the dictates of their client management in assuming an aggressive accounting stance to pass earnings goals.
Learning can also be further enhanced through simulation training as well as role plays, depending on how real-life situations are created to enable students to practice making decisions. Such activities enable the students to learn about the pressure and complexity of the real situation, as well as offer a safe setting in which experimentation and learning may take place.
Such guest lectures by actual practicing professionals who may have encountered such ethical dilemmas can be of immense consequence to the students when it comes to knowing what it is all about to be ethical in actual practice. Such presentations allow students to see that ethical concerns are not merely hypothetical things that occur once in a lifetime but a reality that we must watch over and be principled in our decision-making because this happens every day.
The Technology and Digital Ethics
Digitalization of accounting activities has brought about emerging ethical concerns that should be explored in modern education. Professional responsibility is called into question with the adoption of artificial intelligence in financial reporting, blockchain technology to process transaction verification, and big data analytics to get a better understanding of businesses.
The students need to learn how technology may be used to help as well as jeopardize ethical practice. An example is that although mechanical controls eliminate the chances of mistakes and fraud issues, they may provide new chances of manipulation unless well designed and watched. The rising usages of data analytics in making business decisions mean that accountants facing such ethical demands must be aware of ethical issues involved in collecting, analyzing, and interpreting data.
Creating Ethical Culture by the Means of Education
The development of an ethical culture in the accounting field starts with the classroom. This is not possible without the infusion of ethical content into the curriculum, but it also involves the modeling of ethical behavior by faculty and administration. Students can learn more about ethical issues from the way the instructors treat them than through traditional teaching.
Peer discussion and learning are very important in the process of development of ethical reasoning skills. When students are made to debate the ethical dilemmas, they get to hear the arguments of other people and also learn to state the ethical finding position of their own. Such reflection and discussion make the ethical principles more internal and train people to speak with ethical effectiveness.
Evaluation procedures will also have to undergo changes and meet the significance attached to ethical competency. Technical-aspects-based exams are supposed to be complemented with tests designed to control moral judgment, stakeholder evaluation, and professional decision-making. The process of reflection of the student on her or his ethical development with the pass of years can be the very helpful portfolio-based assessment, which will help to realize to what extent the student is an ethical professional.
Managing the Issue of Implementation
There are some practical issues to undertaking thorough ethical training. The problem of faculty development is also important: numerous accounting teachers do not have many experiences related to ethical teaching. This gap can be covered by the introduction of professional development programs and partnerships with the ethics experts, but to make the implementation successful, institutions need to ensure long-term attendance of the faculty.
Limits on resources also exist mainly when dealing with an institution that has minimal budgets. Nevertheless, alliances with professional bodies, accounting practices, and regulatory agencies offer dealings that encompass case contents, guest lecturers, and financial assistance. Professional bodies in Ghana, such as the Ghana Institute of Chartered Accountants (GICA), can play a very useful role in supporting ethical education activities.
Implementation is also hindered by resistance to change within academic establishments. This could be because some faculty members perceive ethical education as a secondary or even a technical issue compared to training, whereas some of them are not very confident about being able to teach ethics to their students. The solution to these concerns consists of effective leadership of the academic administrators and proper communication to understand the significance of ethical competency in achieving professional success.
Ghanaian context and cultural aspects
The unusual cultural as well as economic situation in Ghana lends significant aspects to the education of ethics of financial reporting. This interconnectedness of people in communities forms the basis of Ubuntu; it helps in appreciating the responsibilities of stakeholders. The students need to be taught to think not only about the success of the immediate stakeholders but also about the community effects of their professional actions.
There are further ethical dilemmas because of the substantial contribution of the informal economy to the economic environment in Ghana. Accounting professionals have the tendency to deal with the enterprise with its existence in the formal and informal sectors, and they need a detailed range of the aspects of reporting and the requirements of stakeholders. Students have to be ready to find their way through these complexities but without compromising professional integrity.
In Ghana there is also the influence of religious and traditional values on ethical decision-making. These values usually concur with professional ethical values, but under certain circumstances, cultural expectations may not be in line with the professional needs. Education should ensure that the students know how to work around these tensions without neglecting their roles as professionals.
The Future: Suggestions to Act
A concerted effort by the various stakeholders would be necessary in transforming the accounting education to accommodate financial reporting ethics better. Colleges and universities have to restructure their programs to teach ethics at every stage of the program and not only in specialized courses in ethics. It is crucial that such an integration starts in basic classes and proceeds through more detailed ones so that students learn to use the whole concept of ethics as second nature.
Professional groups should make contributions by supplying sources, education, and rewards related to ethical training. It will be possible to develop standardized frameworks of ethical competency to ensure conformity among institutions with the flexibility to adapt locally.
Regulatory authorities can identify the need to integrate some ethical requirements on competency in the process of professional certification. It would establish incentives for the institutions and students to focus on the ethical education and show the importance of it to professional practice.
On the part of the employers, they should also inform them of their expectations of being ethical and support them throughout the progress of ethical behavior. This gap may be minimized by bringing in the new graduates and assigning them an experienced professional through mentorship programs.
Conclusion
Accessibility to real-world ethical issues in the teaching of financial reporting extends beyond an academic exercise, but it is the essential core of producing accountants capable of being trusted gatekeepers of financial information in a more complicated world. To retain the current achievement in terms of growth in Ghana, among many other things, the country needs ethical accounting professionals more than ever.
The difficulties are appreciable, but the prospective rewards are even bigger. It would be by the means of doing so that we would be able to raise a generation of accounting professionals with not only the technical expertise that would be expected, but also those that would have the moral backbone and the moral courage to do the right thing, even when it is not easy.
It is better to act now. Our determination to ethical excellence is the future of the accounting profession as a whole and also of the economic prospect of Ghana. By undertaking an in-depth educational reform, establishing close working ties, and remaining committed to ethical principles, we can guarantee that future accountants have the strength to solve problems of tomorrow and retain some of the highest standards of professional ethics.
References
In a study by the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) (2023), it was observed that the adverse effect on the growth and development of young children was frequent. Ethics and trust in finance: a global survey report. Acca Publications London.
Apostolou, B., Rebele, J. E., Dorminey, J. W., and Hassell, J. M. (2015). The ROEG resource material (2013-2014). Accounting education, 33(2), 69-127.
G. Boyce, (2008). Social relevance of ethics teaching to a globalizing world: Dilemmas of the individual to crises of the system. Critical Perspectives on Accounting 19 (2) 255-290.
Dellaportas, S. (2006). It takes a discrete course on accounting ethics to make a difference. Journal of Business Ethics 65(4):391-404.
GICA. Ghana Institute of Chartered Accountants. (2022). Standards and Ethics Framework of Professionals. Accra: GICA publications.
International Federation of Accountants (IFAC). (2023). Handbook of the International Code of Ethics of Professional Accountants. New York: IFAC publications.
Jackling, B., Cooper, B. J., Leung, P., and Dellaportas, S., (2007). The view of professional accounting bodies on the aspect of ethics issues and education. Managerial Auditing Journal 22 (9): 928-944.
Decent Work as a Solution to Crisis: A Sign of Things to Come? (2006, Mintz, S. M.). Ethics in accounting education: The reflection and virtue ethics. Education in Accounting 97-117 (Vol. 24, Issue 2-3).
One is Okafor, C. A. (2018). Ethics in Financial Reporting: An African Perspective. Accra: University of Ghana Press, 2016.
The work by Ponemon, L. A. (1993). Is it possible to teach ethics in accounting? Journal of Accounting Education, No. 11, 2 (185-209).
Sims, R. L., Felton Jr., E. L. (2006). Teaching and learning business ethics design and delivery. Journal of Business Ethics 63 (3). 297-312.
World Bank Group, (2023). Corporate Governance and Financial Reporting Standard in Sub-Saharan Africa. Washington, DC: World Bank Publications.
